Articles Tagged: homemade tonic water

Other Thoughts

Homemade Tonic Water, Post-mortem (Part III)

This is part III in my adventure making my own tonic water. Today, I dissect the recipe posted by Jeffrey Morganthaler and tell you:

a) where I went wrong, and why I won’t do that again…. b) where I think the recipe could be improved and what I will do in attempt #2.

 4 cups water  1 cup chopped lemongrass (roughly one large stalk) // I don’t know if this is a mistake, but I felt that there wasn’t enough lemongrass. This could be my mistake and I did not take a big enough stalk of lemongrass. I’m going to double it next time. Or buy one HUGE stalk of lemongrass. ¼ cup powdered cinchona bark // My mistake. I used cinchona bark chunks. Although I attempted to make a powder using a variety of methods, I failed. And the lack of surface area caused there to not be enough quinine and therefore bitterness. Here’s what I tried: first, I tried putting into a pepper mill. The chunks were too big to properly shred. I tried grinding it in a food processor [overheated] and coffee mill [overheated]. Okay, next time: buy the powder. 

Read More ...

Tonic Water

Aaron’s Homemade Tonic [2012]

homemade tonic 2012

Yesterday I showed you how I made my own tonic syrup. Today, I’m going to review my own tonic water. And tell you where I’m going to go next.

Tasting First, the tonic syrup has a nice thickness to it and a pleasant aroma. Hints of quinine, a bit of a vague herbal aroma, but primarily the citrus comes off a bit strong here. Lots of orange, maybe a hint of lime.

Tasting straight, its rather bracing and sour. Way too much orange and lime. There seems to be an almost “juice-like” element at play in here. Hints of lemonade/orangeade. There’s a little bit of bitterness on the aftertaste, but not as much as you might hope for in a good tonic. You can taste a bit of lemongrass in here, but the vibrancy is drowned out by the overwhelming citrus fruit.

Price: 12.99 for the Chinchona + about $1 for the three citrus fruits + $2 for the lemon grass + $5 for the Citric Acid.  Divide by two since there’s enough for about 2 batches in what I bought. So about $10 / 500 mL Best consumed: Umm, I think it can handle a strong juniper forward gin, but it overwhelms nearly anything that is put in it.

Read More ...

Other Thoughts

Making my Own Tonic Water (Part I)

For my first Tonic Water making experience I followed along with the seminal work on the topic, Jeffrey Morgenthaler’s blog post on the subject from a few years ago. 

Firstly, I gathered all of the ingredients. I found most of the more difficult to find things at Kalustyans in New York

Exercising my zest muscle, zesting a series of citrus fruits. The best part of this is the oils that get all over your hands, and if you’re lucky- spring into your face with each zest.

The first step that I was a little uncertain of, which was juicing each of the three fruits.

1 teaspoon full [more or less] of Allspice Berries

Preparing to chop the Lemongrass

Adding the chopped lemongrass to the mixture.

Add water and bring to a boil

When boiling, lower to a simmer and put a lid on it


I decided to use gravity filtration. It took way too long. Next time I’d choose a french press if I could.

Gravity Filtration in full swing

The completely filtered tonic, before adding the simply syrup

The final syrup is gently heated with the simple syrup mixture.

Read More ...